Happy birthday, S’mac! The East Village eatery (Sarita’s Macaroni & Cheese, S’mac for short, is located at 345 East 12th Street, New York) that fancies up macaroni and cheese turns one today and is celebrating by offering its All-American nosh for just one dollar.
For the record, an All-American is your standard mac and cheese—American and cheddar cheese on your choice of twisted elbow macaroni or whole-wheat pasta, with or without breadcrumbs. The nosh is the smallest size, and usually goes for $4.25. Skillets hang on the wall to help you figure out portion size, but a nosh is perfect if you plan on trying more than. After all, why get your plain Jane macaroni and cheese at a place that specializes in more exotic blends?
Offering up a gooey array of macaroni and cheese skillets, S’mac is a turophile’s dream. Among the cheeses that smother the pasta are American, brie, cheddar, goat cheese, gorgonzola, gruyere, manchego, mozzarella, muenster, parmesan, and pepper jack. If you’re building your own, you can only choose from All American or 4 Cheese sauce so for a more distinctive cheese, go with one of the main macs or current specials.
You can view the complete menu here, smacnyc.com/what.html but the highlights include:
CHEESEBURGER: For the Hearty Meat Eater! Ground Beef done to perfection with onions, garlic and a hint of ketchup and mustard. Don’t forget the best part - a combination of American and Cheddar cheeses.
…
GRUYERE: A Swiss Mac that keeps you coming back for more. Gruyere coupled with its partner in crime, slab bacon. Hard to resist!
…
GARDEN (LITE): Don’t let the “Lite” fool you - this baby is as satisfying as any of the other MACs! Lite Cheddar, Parmesan, roasted cauliflower and portobello mushrooms, roasted garlic, broccoli and scallions.
They also have three specials:
MARSALA MAC: North American comfort food blended with Indian spices - exotic? mysterious? avant-garde? - you be the judge. This one is certainly not for the faint of heart!
BUFFALO CHICKEN MAC: Cheddar & American cheeses with boneless chicken pieces and buffalo wing sauce. We’ll even top it off with crumbled blue cheese if you’d like!
GINGER WASABI MAC: Goat Cheese blended with soy sauce, ginger, wasabi and scallions … who says East can’t meet West!
Be the first to know about the latest specials at S’mac by signing up for the mailing list: keepmeintheloop@smacnyc.com.
Not too daring, I got the 4 Cheese, made of muenster, American, gorgonzola, and cheddar. It was good but not the crunchy baked goodness of Chat’n’Chew’s macaroni and cheese. I also sampled the Marsala Mac, which kicked it up a notch with spicy Indian flavors. I liked the concept of the Brie Mac, which is sprinkled with bits of roasted fig and shiitake mushrooms, but found brie to be a bit overwhelming for macaroni and cheese. The Goat Cheese Mac was heavy on the spinach and light on the Kalamata olives, but was still very tasty.
As for atmosphere, it was very IKEA—cute and modern, but verging on rinky-dink. In classic cafeteria style, you have to clean up for yourself, separating the skillets from the silverware and so forth.
Overall, it’s a fun place to take out-of-towners, who will like the gimmick of a restaurant that servers only one type of food since they’re probably used to only eating at huge chains like Chili’s and Applebees. It’s also a good casual date. I saw one couple sharing a large skillet instead of getting their own smaller ones. Very cute. If you go with a group of friends, I’d recommend each person getting something different and sharing, though.
Here are two fun bits of trivia to work into conversation when you go to S’mac:
Crayola has an orange-ish crayon called Macaroni and Cheese
Thomas Jefferson is rumored to have invented macaroni and cheese.